Book Review: “Animal, Vegetable, Miracle”
I had high hopes for this book by Barbara Kingsolver, an author who I really enjoy reading. Recently, I’ve been making my way through High Tide In Tucson, a collection of essays that has a nice natural history / personal experience / poetic analysis flavor to it. She’s up there with Annie Dillard and Rebecca Solnit as my one of my favorite authors to read. Plus, with the added bonus of this book being about farming and a year of eating local, it sounded like it would be right up my alley.
In many ways it was — I really enjoyed the stories about the family’s farm, their exploits with an apparently massive garden, and their impressive flock of poultry (chickens and turkeys). I picked up a lot of little tidbits about things I’d been wondering in the back of my mind (there is discussion of root cellaring fall vegetables and braiding up the garlic after it’s been harvested.) I want to try making some cheese after reading about how they do it. The recipes are also inspiring, though I’ve got to say that I aspire to be more of a vegetarian than I can ever pull off. Overall, it was an enjoyable read that had a lot I could identify with and be inspired by.
I guess the problem was that I went into it with really high expectations. I’ve read a couple books over the last year or so that have really affected the way I think about food: Plenty, a book by a Vancouver couple who eat a really strict 100-mile diet for a year, and The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Michael Pollan’s comprehensive look at food systems in the US. I had already read all the arguments and I was convinced, so more information about how bad things really are was a little too much. The narrative walking through the rhythm of the seasons was interesting, but the obligatory facts and arguments got in the way of the thing I was hoping for — the inspiration promised in the title. Animal, Vegetable, Miracle… it’s an amazing title, so ripe with promise; honestly, maybe a little too much for the book to live up to. I guess I was looking for more poetry, more magic, and in the end it was just a lot of normal common sense. Which is kind of Kingsolver’s point, as she looks at the world and wonders why it seems so completely foreign that her family would try to eat only the things they grow or buy locally for a year.
There is nothing like an overdue library book to get me to finish something I’ve been working on 5 pages at a time for the last few weeks. With lots of free time over Thanksgiving, I finally finished it off and I have no regrets. It’s a great book, and I learned a lot (and I wish I could have a turkey raising operation, but there just isn’t room). But maybe I will find room for a root cellar in the basement, and hopefully we will come to understand the ways our lives and our food interact. And we will keep putting things in the ground and watching them come up, slowly at first, then exploding in the miracle of great abundance.
Thanks to Kendall for letting me know about this book on One / Change.






